Saturday, April 9, 2016

Are Living Books and Classics One and of the Same?...

After posting A Matter of Principle, one faithful follower posed some questions regarding Charlotte's statement, "...not the works of every playwright and novelist are good 'for example of life and instruction in manners.' We are safest with those which have lived long enough to become classics; and this, for two reasons. The fact that they have not been allowed to die proves in itself that the authors have that to say, and a way of saying it, which the world cannot do without. In the next place, the older novels and plays deal with conduct, and conduct is our chief concern in life. Modern works of the kind deal largely with emotions, a less wholesome subject of contemplation."  

The reader asked the following, 
...I found something you stated to be a worthy thought and something that has been on my mind lately. You pointed this out: Modern works of the kind deal largely with emotions, a less wholesome subject of contemplation (as per Mrs. Mason)....I am curious as to your thoughts about it? What would you consider 'modern' to be? How modern is modern? We were reading a bio of Beethoven and something in there caught my attention that said "He came up with new, thrilling, and expressive ways of putting musical sounds together that changed the history of music forever. Ludwig's music let people FEEL things about the joy, sadness, stress of life. It was something loud and exciting, and often beautiful enough to give your goose bumps all over..." Now, Ludwig was born in 1770. We are talking VERY OLD. Yet, since his composing, the music industry has changed and we are now driven by music that plays very heavy on our emotions. One example, most of his music had a continuous melody through the symphony that was only 4 notes (the shortest). That was the 'tune'. I know some great modern music that only has few notes repeating and repeating itself and is absolutely amazing. But, again, emotional. I often hear in CM circles to choose books that would 'touch the heart'. Oh, they often do. But again, would you consider that to be under 'emotions driven' and most importantly, is that what CM meant? Because if so, what we think to be today's modern stuff, might not even be close to what she meant by it....
I've been pondering the reader's questions because I thought they were great.  I decided to put my thoughts in a post, for whatever it's worth.

In order to answer the questions posed, I think we would have to ask another question.  Are a living book and a classic book the same?  It appears as though Charlotte uses the terms ‘living’ and ‘classic’ differently in her writing and I wonder if this is where the question lies.

In Charlotte's quote, she refers to books that have become "classics" for two reasons: (1) the fact that they have not been allowed to die proves in itself that the authors have that to say, and a way of saying it, which the world cannot do without; and (2) the older novels and plays deal with conduct, and conduct is our chief concern in life.

According to Invitation to the Classics, edited byCowan and Guinness, classics exhibit distinguished style, fine artistry, and keen intellect, as well as creating whole universes of imagination and thought.  They portray life as multifaceted, depicting both positive and negative aspects of human character. They have a transforming effect on the reader's self-understanding.  They invite and survive frequent re-readings.  They are considered classics by large numbers of people and their appeal endures over wide reaches of time.  The Classics also often refer to books in the Western Canon, or the body of books, music, and art that have been most influential in shaping Western Civilization. In the above quote, I believe this is what Charlotte is referring to. 

On the other hand, living books as defined in blog land and on the Simply Charlotte Mason website are, "…books {that} are usually written by one person who has a passion for the subject and writes in conversational or narrative style. The books pull you into the subject and involve your emotions, so it’s easy to remember the events and facts.  Living books make the subject ‘come alive.’ They can be contrasted to dry writing, like what is found in most encyclopedias or textbooks, which basically lists informational facts in summary form."  I believe this may be what the reader was referring to...and I hope she'll correct me if I'm wrong.

In Principle 12, Charlotte refers to Education being the Science of Relations.  In Volume 3, Charlotte says,
I do not mean that he should know all these things; but he should feel, when he reads of it in the newspapers, the thrill which stirred the Cretan peasants when the frescoes in the palace of King Minos were disclosed to the labour of their spades. He should feel the thrill, not from mere contiguity, but because he has with the past the relationship of living pulsing thought; and, if blood be thicker than water, thought is more quickening than blood. He must have a living relationship with the present, its historic movement, its science, literature, art, social needs and aspirations. In fact, he must have a wide outlook, intimate relations all round; and force, virtue, must pass out of him, whether of hand, will, or sympathy, wherever he touches.
We know that Charlotte advocated the use of 'living books' and the SCM definition would definitely contradict her statement about modern literature being negative because it deals with emotion if she used the words 'living' and 'classic' interchangeably.  However, in reading the original quote in question in its entirety, Charlotte uses the word “classics” rather than living books.  This leads me to believe she means two different things.  Charlotte definitely advocated using living books to spark living ideas and this would be the tie to emotion, but I don't believe this is the same as the original reference above.  

I personally see a living book as being somewhat more subjective than a classic.  Yes, there are some similarities.  However, whether or not the reader makes an emotional connection with a living book depends on the reader and what experiences they've encountered prior to their reading.  Whereas a classic is considered as such by a larger group of people and could have been influential in shaping Western Civilization.   With that said, I do think a classic can be a living book and a living book can be a classic.  But, based on the criteria above, a living book may not always be considered a classic.

Stay with me here...


When I look up the word "classic" in my new American Dictionary of the English Language by Noah Webster 1828, it says,
(1) An author of the first rank; a writer whose style is pure, correct, and refined; primarily, a Greek or Roman author of this character; but the word is applied to writers of a like character in any nation. 
(2) A book written by an author of the first class 
Here, we see that relation to Greece and Rome, or the shaping of Western Culture.  Now, when I think about a book like Swallows and Amazons by English author Arthur Ransome, which was published in 1930, seven years after Charlotte published A Philosophy of Education, I would consider it a living book, which by some, has been deemed a classic.  Certainly Ransome would have been Mason's contemporary and considered modern in her time.  Does Swallows and Amazons appeal to emotion rather than conduct or character?  I would argue it does not.

This prompts me to think, if Charlotte referred to modern works of her time as being emotional, I wonder what she would say about modern literature now, nearly 100 years later.  Obviously, modern to her didn't mean the same as modern to us.  And, have some of the works she was referring to become what we call classics over that time?  Since she's not here to ask, it's hard to say.  

By the way, I don't know that there is a specific amount of time that must pass in order to make a book a classic.  I have read a variety of debates ranging from twenty to fifty and even one hundred years.  If we consider books from Greece and Rome, we're talking over 2,000 years.  Some living book connoisseur's advise staying away from anything published after the 1950's, particularly regarding children's literature, but again, this is not necessarily related to classics.

Either way, after re-reading Charlotte's original quote several times, I believe her point was to suggest choosing books that deal with conduct, rather than emotion.  Ultimately, the decision of which books should be chosen remains to be seen, as the debate of whether a book is classic rages on.  As Cowan and Guinness point out,
The body of these masterworks thus shifts and changes constantly in the course of time.  Plato, who was passed over in the late medieval world in favor of his disciple Aristotle, became a dominant philosopher in the Renaissance; Thomas Aquinas the learned founder of Scholasticism, has been in modern times largely relegated to seminaries; Francis Bacon has declined to the role of a minor eccentric.  Even Shakespeare, now often described as the world's greatest poet, has not always been considered a classic author; the eighteenth century decried his lack of taste and rewrote several of his plays....Virgil's Aeneid seems, regrettably, to be losing some of its position in recent times.  But the Iliad and the Odyssey hold their foremost place as firmly as when Plato cited Homer nearly twenty-five hundred years ago, or when, at the turn of the century, most college students read them in Greek.
To place a contemporary writing among the classics, then, is to make a bold conjecture.  That conjecture is based on the judgement of a sufficiently large body of readers in current society who consider the work a masterpiece.  But the book in question has to be worth their endorsement.  All the popular acclaim in the world will not make a classic of mediocre text.  
...We could argue that, since the real existence of masterpieces is beyond time, we should not have to wait for time to make its judgment on newcomers.  A recently published work might be seen by perceptive readers to take its place among its predecessors and to converse amicably with them.  The sensitive reader should be able to judge. (Invitation to the Classics, p. 22) 
Some of Charlotte's contemporaries and beyond that Cowan and Guinness include in Invitation to the Classics are Nathaniel Hawthorne, Emily Dickinson, Herman Melville, Gustave Flaubert, Charles Dickens, George Eliot, Leo Tolstoy, Fyodor Dostoyevsky, Mark Twain, Friedrich Nietzsche, Joseph Conrad, William Butler Yeats, T.S. Eliot, Robert Frost, C.S. Lewis, William Faulkner, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Flannery O'Connor, and another that I would add that wasn't in their list is Wendell Berry.  These authors would be more suited for upper high school and adults.

Authors I would consider worthy for children and young adult would be Louisa May Alcott, C.W. Anderson, Thornton Burgess, Paul Bunyan, Alfred Church, Charles Coffin, Padraic Colum, Alice Dalgleish, James Daugherty, Edgar and Ingri D'Aulaire, Marguerite DeAngeli, Daniel DeFoe, Mary Mapes Dodge, Genevieve Foster, H.A. Guerber, Marguerite Henry, G.A. Henty, V.M. Hillyer, Stewart Holbrook, Holling C. Holling, Clara Ingram Judson, Rudyard Kipling, Jean Lee Latham, George MacDonald, Robert McCloskey, Ralph Moody, Lucy Fitch Perkins, Beatrix Potter, Howard Pyle, Arthur Ransome, Kate Seredy, Rosemary Sutcliff, Opal Wheeler, and Laura Ingalls Wilder.  I don't mean to imply that they've all written classics, but I do believe their books are living.

I am still pondering all of this and would love to have further discussion in the comments if anyone is so inclined :))

Friday, April 8, 2016

Friday Findings: Finland's Education System, Play and Learning, Creating Independent Learners, Morning Time with LIttles....

Here we are again at Friday!  I've been away for the past couple of Friday Findings, but still have a few new links.

I read 11 Ways Finland's Education System Shows Us "Less is More" some weeks back and found it fascinating.  It think they're on to something.

While in Cincinnati, I had the opportunity to hear Dr. Christopher Perrin speak.  I greatly appreciate his knowledge and approach. Yesterday, I came across this video clip on Play and Learning.  It's a shortened version of one of his conference talks.

One of my favorite things is sitting next to my children with a book.  On the other hand, I do have a child that can milk it for all it's worth.  Knowing where to draw the line between dependence and independence can be a challenge, which Harvey and Laurie Bluedorn address in Sit By Me, Mom.

And, if you're a book junkie like me, you may appreciate Heidi's Reading List Challenge 2016 - March. Her list looks fabulous....and a little daunting at the same time.

Lastly, we listened to podcasts most of the way to and from Cincinnati, which I absolutely LOVE!  Digital technology is amazing!  Most recently, I listened to Morning Time with Littles, a conversation between Pam Barnhill and Celeste Cruz.  Celeste has some fabulous ideas for successfully incorporating morning time with a house full of little people.  Her perspective on expectation and creating the habit of attention are spot on.

Today, I leave you with photos of the latest farm project....new calves for kids :)




Wednesday, April 6, 2016

A Matter of Principle....


Principle 19

Therefore, children should be taught, as they become mature enough to understand such teaching, that the chief responsibility which rests on them as persons is the acceptance or rejection of ideas.  To help them in this choice we give them principles of conduct, and a wide range of the knowledge fitted to them.  These principles should save children from some of the loose thinking and heedless action which cause most of us to live at a lower level than we need.  

principle = a fundamental truth or proposition that serves as the foundation for a system of belief or behavior or for a chain of reasoning

According to Charlotte everyone has principles - that is, everyone has a few chief and leading opinions upon which every bit of his conduct is based.  She further asserts,
It is an interesting fact, that, though a person's principles of conduct are often not put into words, they are always written in characters of their own.  Everyone carries his rules of conduct writ large upon his countenance, that he who runs may read.  
We gather our principles unconsciously; but they are our masters; and it is our business every now and then to catch one of them, look it in the face, and question ourselves as to the manner of conduct such a principle must bring forth.  (Vol. 4, Ourselves)
I thought of Charlotte's words today as I read aloud Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry by Mildred D. Taylor.  In Chapter 7 we found out that Stacey gave his new much needed coat to T.J.  The coat was originally given to Stacey as a gift from Uncle Hammer, but was too big.  When Mama tells Stacey to go get the coat so she can hem the sleeves, he stammers around until he's forced to admit giving the coat away because it was too big and T.J. told him he looked like a fat preacher in it.  After some back and forth dialog, the story goes like this...
"Now you hear me good on this - look at me when I talk to you, boy!"   Immediately Stacey raised  his head and looked at Uncle Hammer.  "If you ain't got the brains of a flea to see that this T.J. fellow made a fool of you, then you'll never get anywhere in this world.  It's tough out there, boy, and as long as there are people, there's going to be somebody trying to take what you got and trying to drag you down.  It's up to you whether you let them or not.  Now it seems to me you wanted that coat when I gave it to you, ain't that right?"
Stacey managed a shaky "Yessir."
"And anybody with any sense would know it's a good thing, ain't that right?"
This time Stacey could only nod. 
"Then if you want something and it's a good thing and you got it in the right way, you better hang on to it and don't let nobody talk you out of it.  You care what a lot of useless people say 'bout you you'll never get anywhere, 'cause there's a lotta folks don't want you to make it.  You understand what I'm telling you?"
"Y-yessir, Uncle Hammer," Stacey stammered.  Uncle Hammer turned then and went back to his paper without having laid a hand on Stacey, but Stacey shook visibly from the encounter.
A few pages later, we encounter T.J. "obnoxiously flaunting Stacey's wool coat" during the cold days of December.  Apparently, the coat fit T.J. perfectly and he was bragging about the beauty and fit of it.  The author then writes...
Stacey was restrained from plugging T.J.'s mouth by Uncle Hammer's principle that a man did not blame others for his own stupidity; he learned from his mistake and became stronger for it.  
Here we have a perfect example of conduct based on principle.  Stacey carelessly gave his new coat away, giving in to peer pressure.  Based upon Stacey's character earlier in the story, the reader knows it's likely he will fight to get his coat back.  However, after knowledge fitted to him from Uncle Hammer, Stacey realizes his mistake and that he cannot blame someone else for his failure.  Instead of beating T.J. up for his own personal shortcoming, he chalks it up to a lesson learned.  Stacey's conscience remembered Uncle Hammer's principle and steered his conduct.

Next, Charlotte addresses how we should teach children these principles of conduct.
But how is the conscience to become instructed?  Life brings us many lessons: when we see others do well, conscience approves and learns; when others do ill, conscience condemns.  But we want a wider range of knowledge than the life about us affords, and books are our best teachers.
There is no nice shade of conduct which is not described or exemplified in the vast treasure-house of literature.  History and biography are full of instruction in righteousness; but what is properly called literature, that is, poetry, essays, the drama, and novels, is perhaps the most useful for our moral instruction, because the authors bring their insight to bear in a way they would hesitate to employ when writing about actual persons.  Autobiographies, again, often lift the veil, for the writer may make free with himself.  In the Bible the lives of men and the history of a nation are told without the reticence which authors are apt to use in telling of the offences of the good or the vices of the bad.  Plutarch, perhaps alone among biographies, writes with comparable candour, if not always with equal justice.  
Charlotte also includes Psalms, Proverbs, dramatists and novelists in her list.  However, she does caution us, saying,
...not the works of every playwright and novelist are good 'for example of life and instruction in manners.' We are safest with those which have lived long enough to become classics; and this, for two reasons.  The fact that they have not been allowed to die proves in itself that the authors have that to say, and a way of saying it, which the world cannot do without.  In the next place, the older novels and plays deal with conduct, and conduct is our chief concern in life. Modern works of the kind deal largely with emotions, a less wholesome subject of contemplation.
I find that final sentence fascinating in today's world of political correctness.  Heaven forbid we should call a spade a spade for fear that it may be offensive.  Our society is extremely emotionally charged, and therefore, not producing the great thinkers of the past.  There is panic and pandemonium, rather than leisurely contemplation and deep thought.

Ironically, Charlotte didn't encourage reading books simply for their principles, but stated,
...the way such teaching should come to us is, here a little and there a little, incidentally, from books which we read for the interest of the story, the beauty of the poem, or the grace of the writing.  
This ties directly to classical education, which purports truth, beauty, and goodness.  We should choose classic works that have stood the test of time.  They should be interesting, have beautiful language, and will guide our conduct by their grace and goodness.  

In the last section of our assigned reading, Charlotte addresses conscience.
Everybody knows that the affairs of his body and those of his heart should be ordered by his conscience.  
Charlotte gives examples that illustrate how easy it is for an idle mind to "lie in wait for any chance notion that comes floating their way, take it up zealously, and make it their business in life to spread it."  She demonstrates how fallacies work and concludes with,
There is ever some new fallacy in the air which allures its thousands, and no one is safe who is not cognisant of danger, and who does not know how to safeguard himself.  Perhaps no rules for the right conduct of life are more important than the following: (a) that we may not play with chance opinions; (b) that our own Reason affords an insufficient test of the value of an opinion (because Reason, as we have seen, argues in behalf of Inclination); (c) that we must labour to get knowledge as the foundation of opinions; (d) that we must also labour to arrive at principles whereby to try our opinions. 
In the end, Charlotte calls us to labour, form with toil and care, till, and cultivate to help our children obtain knowledge.  We must then allow them to form opinions based on that knowledge that can be tested under the safety of our wing.  Giving them principles on which to base their conduct so they can soar at the highest possible level.

Monday, April 4, 2016

Home Again, Home Again, Jiggety Jig...

I'm trying to get my bearings today after being gone for five days to the Midwest Great Homeschool Convention.  I'm working through mounds of laundry and, since the house looked like tornado alley upon arriving home, cleaning.  The good news, after a week off, we did manage to finish our lessons uneventfully the morning.

Now, I must say, the convention was fabulous and well worth the extra work at home!  I'm still coming down.  Speakers like Dr. Inge Auerbacher, Martin Cothran, Andrew Kern, Dr. Christopher Perrin, Dr. Carol Reynolds, and Ann Voskamp rocked!  RileyAnn and I also really enjoyed entertainment by The Willis Clan.  Exhibits such as Beautiful Feet, Center for Lit, CiRCE Institute, Classical Academic Press, Memoria Press, Rainbow Resource, Simply Charlotte Mason, Sonlight, and Veritas Press made my day.  

After the past year of blogging for Beautiful Feet, I was finally able to meet Josh Berg personally.  Putting a face with the name and e-mail correspondence sure is nice.  Also, I drew great wisdom from time spent speaking to folks like Ian Andrews, Martin Cothran, Andrew Kern and Dr. Christopher Perrin.  Thoughts and ideas have been swimming in my mind since.  There will be future posts as I digest what I've learned.  But for now, below are some sights and scenes from Cincinnati...









Tuesday, March 29, 2016

The Unhurried Homeschooler....


In preparation for the GHC, I'm making my lists and checking them twice.  In the fall, I'll be 'teaching' 4K, 6th, and 7th grade.  This morning as I was nearing hyperventilation stage at the thought, I listened to Homeschool Snapshots Podcast 28, Unhurried Homeschooling with Pam Barnhill and Durenda Wilson.  I so appreciate perspective from veteran homeschooling moms like Durenda.  She has eight children ranging from age 11 to young adult homeschool graduates, a couple of which are married and carrying on the tradition with grandchildren.  After listening to the podcast, I felt better and would love to get my hands on a copy of her book, The Unhurried Homeschooler.

In poking around her blog, Simple Nourishing Home, I came across a video interview Durenda did with her third child, Jake, who, at that time, was a 19-year old college student.  In the intereview, Jake shares his homeschool experience and encourages homeschooling families.  I find it very reassuring when I hear homeschool graduates adamantly profess the power of homeschooling and their plans to continue with their children.  The Interview with Jake is a great testament to homeschooling.  There's no need for hyperventilation ;-)


Monday, March 28, 2016

I'm Going to a Great Homeschool Convention!!...

I can hardly contain myself!  The Great Homeschool Convention is something I've dreamed about attending for a couple of years and this year that dream is becoming reality.  I've been attending the MACHE conference every year since I began homeschooling eight years ago, which is a great conference to cut your teeth on.  However this year, I wanted to spread my wings so two other local homeschooling moms and I are heading Ohio.

I'm excited about this for a couple of reasons.  First, there will be a variety of speakers that don't normally come this far north, including Andrew Kern, Dr. Christopher Perrin, and Martin Cothran, to name a few. Judging by the list of speakers, it appears at though the GHC is geared for classical educators, which totally peaks my interest.

Secondly, I really look forward to community.  Some may say that in this generation of webinars and podcasts, you can listen to many of your favorite speakers online, in the comfort of your own home, and often times free.  This is true.  However, there is nothing like building face to face community.  My favorite part of MACHE last year was networking.  I loved hanging around exhibit booths like Simply Charlotte Mason.  It was here, that I was able to bounce ideas, touch, smell, and feel resources to get a better sense of whether or not they may work for my family.  I also met other like minded families that became fast friends.  The GHC offers a huge exhibit hall, again, with many vendors that don't normally come my way, such as Beautiful Feet, CiRCE Institute, Classical Academic Press, Queen Homeschool Supplies, Inc., Royal Fireworks Press, and Veritas Press.  I can hardly wait to check out their products in person!

If you are thinking about trying a homeschool conference this season or would like pointers to get the most out of your conference, consider Preparing for a Homeschool Convention.  Also, Pam Barnhill did a great follow-up video to the GHC in Greenville, SC, that was super helpful if you're planning to attend a conference.

Lastly, if you are going to the GHC in OH, let me know in the comments below.  If you happen to see me in OH, please do stop and chat.  I would absolutely LOVE to meet some of my readers and online blogging friends :))

Monday, March 21, 2016

Were You There, When They Crucified My Lord? A Break for Holy Week....

I aim to take a mini sabbatical from blogging this week in honor of Holy Week.  I will have a new post ready for you next Monday, God willing :)

Today I wanted to share one of my favorite hymns for this time of year, which we sang in church yesterday...


 

May you have a blessed Resurrection Season,

Melissa

Friday, March 18, 2016

Friday Findings: Civilization Suicide, What's Affecting Our Elections, ADHD, Portrait of a Graduate, and a Little Laundry Secret....

This week has felt like a whirlwind!  I've been on the road more than I've been home and this makes me a little cantankerous.  You see, I actually like being home where I can see my piles dwindle instead of accumulate.  Sadly, the next couple of weeks will be more of the same.  Hopefully, in the long run, it will balance and all be worth it :)

On the web, have you read Our Schools Are Committing 'Civilization Suicide'?  At first glance, it seems a little harsh, but I think he has an excellent point and may it be a wake up call.

After reading the above article, I did some further snooping around on the site and found a couple more intriguing posts...

Americans Don't Read...And That's Affecting Our Elections - this is definitely food for thought!

Are We Misdiagnosing Immaturity for ADHD? - I have actually wondered this in the past.  Also, the fact that kids are not allowed to be kids, romping and running in the sunshine, I believe, is a huge contributing factor.  Sadly, I just heard a mom share that her son was misbehaving in school so he will have to stay in for recess to complete lagging school work.  These sorts of stories break my heart as this little boy needs to burn some energy more than anything.  I fear taking away that outlet, recess, is only going to exacerbate the issue.

Lastly, I love what Mystie says in Portrait of a Graduate about educating ourselves so we can be good imitators for our children.  I actually think it goes right along with a couple of the above mentioned posts.  If we expect a love of learning from our kids, then we need to be committed to continuing our education and modeling that attitude.

Do you know about Fels-Naptha Laundry Bar Soap?  It's a little old laundry trick that keeps my sanity because we're in the middle of good old Wisconsin mud season here and the boys are loving it...






Wednesday, March 16, 2016

Rascal...

I didn't know much about Sterling North, nor his book Rascal when we began reading as part of our Beautiful Feet Modern American and World History study.  But, once we started, I was delighted to learn the story took place in our native Wisconsin and was based on a true story.

Rascal is a coming of age story about Sterling North in his boyhood.  Sterling's mother is deceased and his father travels a great deal, leaving Sterling to fend for himself.  One day, Sterling and his friend Oscar find an orphaned baby raccoon and decide to take it to Oscar's house, where his mother nurses it with a wheat straw.  Oscar's parents don't allow him to keep the raccoon so Sterling ends up taking it home.  He names him Rascal.

The story covers a one year period and is primarily concerned with Sterling's adventures with and love for Rascal.  As Rascal grows he becomes more of a nuisance and Sterling has to decide whether or not to keep him.  There's so much more to the story, but I don't want to give it away for those who've not yet read it.  I will suffice to say, that it's a wonderful book for boys, as well as your nature and animal lovers.  Though some history is involved since the story takes place at the end of WWI, I thought there was just as much or more science involved.

After reading the book, we did watch the 1969 Disney DVD.  Unfortunately, the book and movie are totally different.  Of course, the book was better and I would highly recommend reading it before watching the movie.  On the other hand, the film is great for family movie night.  It really was enjoyable for young and old.

Monday, March 14, 2016

Contemplating Classical Education: Recovering The Lost Tools of Learning...

As part of my classical education study, I've been reading Recovering the Lost Tools of Learning by Douglas Wilson.  You may remember from a former post, Wilson piloted Logos School in response to Dorothy Sayers' essay, The Lost Tools of Learning.  At the time of penning his book, Wilson had ten years of experience with Logos School.  He advocates for Christ Centered and Classical education.

Over the weekend, I also listened to a free MP3 podcast Defending Sayers' Insight, in which Wilson defends, or maybe clarifies is a better word, Sayers' essay.  Wilson states the heart of Sayers' essay is taking the Trivium and dividing it up into the stages of learning.  He says, "Her argument is that the Trivium should be applied in a foundational way, giving the kids the tools of learning.  After which point, they can go on to complete the seven liberal arts in their study of the Quadrivium.  So the Trivium comes first.  Grammar first, then dialectic, then rhetoric, and then you can go on to study the Quadrivium."

Wilson goes on to admit, in the beginning, not knowing anything about the Trivium except from what Sayers' wrote, of which is the method he applied at the start of Logos School.  He states, "We began from a position of ignorance...We were just taking what we could from Sayers and putting it into practice....and the practical results from this were just astonishing."  As time went on and they put this method into practice, Wilson states they also furthered their study of classical education.  He is quick to add that Sayers stated in her essay she is confident that no one would ever attempt what she was writing about.  I believe she had no idea how much lower public education would fall and how desperate we would become....ahem!  

Wilson goes on to speculate about Sayers' intentions in writing The Lost Tools of Writing,...
A lot rides on whether we describe what Sayers was advocating as her historical explication of the medieval practice, or instead of this, describing it as the Sayers' insight.  Is this Sayers recounting and interpretation of what the Medieval's did, or is this Sayers saying look what the Medieval's did and I'm suggesting that we apply it in a new and unique way?  So is this Sayers' explication or is this Sayers' insight?  
Wilson proceeds to reference and quote from the book, Wisdom and Eloquence: A Christian Paradigm for Classical Learning by Robert Littlejohn and Charles T. Evans, "The historic application of the Trivium was not done on the Sayers' model."  I will leave you to decipher the rest of the podcast and will suffice to say, it was excellent and cleared up some misconceptions I personally had about Sayers' essay. I was very intrigued by her confidence that no one would take it all that serious.  By the way, the essay was originally presented as a speech at Oxford in 1947.

In regard to Wilson's book, he advocates for educational reforms from phonics instruction to requiring proficiency in certain basic subjects.  At the beginning of Chapter Seven, he writes,
I'D LIKE AN EDUCATION - TO GO
In modern America, the fast-food mentality has penetrated the realm of the mind.  The modern student has a mind full of McThoughts.  Information comes to him processed and prepackaged, and he does his duty as a consumer.  This does not mean that intellectual activity has disappeared, but having your mind full of mental "stuff" is not the same thing as thinking.  
Wilson goes on to explain how the Trivium is applied at Logos School.  However, the book was written in 1991 and the MP3 speech referenced above was given in 2008.  I have a few pages left in Wilson's book, but it does appear that some of his philosophy has changed slightly since he wrote it.  I suspect this is due to aforementioned further study of classical education.

I personally respect and appreciate Wilson's thoughts on Classical education, but find myself filtering it through a Charlotte Mason lens.

In poking around on the AO Forum, I came across a couple relevant posts by Brandy Vencel:

Classical Education: Is Dorothy Sayers the Only Way?

Is Charlotte Mason Classical? {A Follow-Up} 

I would highly encourage you to read the comments after reading each of these posts.  There's excellent food for thought there!  

Friday, March 11, 2016

Friday Findings: The Book Most People Have Lied About Reading, Homeschooling with Dyslexia....

Spring has sprung on Drywood Creek and the calves are coming.  RileyAnn helped her dad pull one earlier this week as the first calf heifer was having some trouble delivering on her own.  There's nothing like a little hands-on science ;-)

I don't have many links this week because I haven't had much time on the computer.  I spoke to a mom's group Tuesday, so spent last weekend prepping.  I also signed the kids up for baseball/softball this week and with Lenten season at church, art, and choir, we've been on the run.

I did get a chance to listen to this fabulous podcast between Pam Barnhill and Marianne Sunderland. Sunderland's insight on homeschooling kids with dyslexia is so helpful...and her kids have accomplished some fascinating feats in their young lives.

A friend sent me This Website Shows You What It's Like Trying To Read When You Have Dyslexia.  Watching the animated JavaScript actually makes me crazy!

Have you ever lied about reading a book?  Apparently, people do.  Check out, The book most people have lied about reading - and it's not War and Peace.  I found this very interesting.  I won't give away the book, but it was a bit unbelievable.  I wonder what prompts folks to lie about it?  Riley laughed because she recently really did read the book most lied about.

I do have some crazy boy pictures for you this week.   A couple days before the snow melted, this was a favorite past time...YIKES!!



Wednesday, March 9, 2016

Do You Really Know Charlotte Mason?, Reflections on a 101...


I had an opportunity to speak to a group of homeschooling moms yesterday about Charlotte Mason.  I felt blessed to be able to share and hope that someone else was blessed by hearing about her philosophy/methods.

It's really hard to put Charlotte Mason in a nutshell.  I had eight pages of notes!  Thankfully, a couple of gals spoke before me, introducing Charlotte and giving an overview of how they use Ambleside Online.  It allowed me to cut part of the introductory stuff.  Today, I thought I would share some links I used as the basis of my notes....

Who was Charlotte Mason? 



What was her philosophy/method of education? 



I also highlighted what I felt were some of Charlotte's key principles:  


Principles 5-8 – Education is an atmosphere, a discipline, a life.  (PNEU motto)
  

  

The goal of narration is the composition of thought. 



What a CM education is not. 



A Charlotte Mason education is not fluffy, light, nor tiptoeing through the tulips.  Check out this List of Attainments.  

How is it relevant today? 


How to apply Charlotte's principles/methods in your homeschool.

Habits are an important part of a Charlotte Mason education, as is parenting in general. 


Just as it is on the whole easier for the locomotive to pursue its way on the rails than to take a disastrous run off them, so it is easier for the child to follow lines of habit carefully laid down than to run off these lines at his peril.  It follows that this business of laying down lines towards the unexplored country of the child’s future is a very serious and responsible one for the parent. (Vol. 1, p. 9)

The mother who takes pains to endow her children with good habits secures for herself smooth and easy days; while she who lets their habits take care of themselves has a weary life of endless friction with the children. All day she is crying out, 'Do this!' and they do it not; 'Do that!' and they do the other. (Vol. 1, p. 136)

Focus on one habit at a time - may take weeks or months per habit 
Motivate by using living examples – find person who exhibits the character quality you’re working on

1. Charlotte’s top three habits: attention, obedience, and truthfulness
            Habit of Attention
-       Use short Lessons - beginning around age 6
-       Set time limits taking child’s attention span into consideration
-       Grades 1-3 15-20 minutes
-       Grades 4-6 20-30 minutes
-       Grades 7-9 30-45 minutes
-       Vary order of lessons - Lessons should range a large variety of subjects altering between concentrated intense subjects and less intense subjects including those that allow for physical movement - Using different parts of the brain allows for better attention span and concentration
-       Don’t repeat yourself
-       Play games that foster attention
-       Develop the habit of best effort by encouraging quality not quantity – you will be able to accomplish much in a short amount of time
-       Charlotte Mason used the best books, the best music, and the best art possible
Obedience
-       Never give a command you don’t intend to see fully carried out
-       Expect obedience – use natural consequences and encouragement
-       Don’t pester child with excessive commands (Ephesians 6:4 Fathers, do not provoke your children to anger, but bring them up in the discipline and instruction of the Lord.)
-       Plan ahead for transition times
Truthfulness
-       Require exact facts without omission or exaggeration
-       Avoid qualifying statements
-       Don’t use excessive language for common situations
-       If needed, have daily lesson in truthful reporting
2. Living Books
-       Stands the test of time – you want to read again – usually written by one person
-       Touches emotion; you develop a relationship with characters; “finishing the book is like saying goodbye to an old friend”
-       Gives you ideas; sparks imagination & creativity; makes you want to further your study
-       Avoid “twaddle” – talking down to the child; diluted; light/fluffy; promotes laziness of the mind; liken to junk food (snack before supper)
            -    choose books with substance

Charlotte’s method incorporates many core subjects including history, geography, Bible, math, science, foreign language, reading, writing, spelling, grammar, art, music & hymn study, literature, poetry, and handicrafts.  I broke down some of the methods used in core subjects.  

History - Living books, biographies, autobiographies, narration, Book of Centuries

Geography - Living books, biographies, autobiographies, travelogues, narration, map drill 

Bible - Read directly from the bible (King James version), narration, memorize and recite scripture, commentaries

Language Arts - The goal of language arts is be able to use language proficiently in order to communicate an idea.  It includes everything that relates to listening, speaking, reading, and writing.  Charlotte Mason's methods included: copywork, narration, prepared dictation, grammar, beginning reading, reading for instruction, recitation, and poetry.  Through these methods, she taught the language arts skills of handwriting, composition, spelling, punctuation, capitalization, parts of speech, sentence structure, vocabulary, how to read, reading comprehension, listening comprehension, and public speaking.

Math - Manipulatives, a firm understanding of why, mental math

Science - Nature study and notebook, living books, narration

What curricula/books work well with the CM method?


Sonlight Book Lists                                                                  Heart of Dakota
Lifetime Books & Gifts                                                            Queen Homeschool
Lamplighter Publishing                                                              Nothing New Press
Bethlehem Books                                                                     Five in a Row
WinterPromise                                                                         TruthQuest History
Yesterday’s Classics                                                                Beautiful Feet
Mott Media – Ruth Beechick books & website                         Greenleaf Press
Ray’s Arithmetic                                                                       Math-U-See
RightStart Math                                                                        Apologia Science


How to modify the CM method for struggling learners? 




Saturday, March 5, 2016

What Then, Shall We Read?...Modern vs. Classic

I love making connections, forming ideas, building knowledge.  Most recently, this idea of reading older, classic works of literature versus new modern works and bestsellers has been on my radar.  The more I read classic works, the more value I see in them.  I rather enjoy older novels for their rich language and deep thought.

Last week, in Friday Findings, I linked The Modern Place for Older Books written by Wendi Capehart at Archipelago because I loved Charlotte Mason's idea of reading books written in a certain time period as you study that period in history.  Of course Archipelago is the blog of Ambleside Online, a free Charlotte Mason curricula utilized primarily by homeschoolers.  Many of the books used in AO are older classic works.

Yesterday, I read Punctuation in Novels, which gave an interesting visual comparison of punctuation in a William Faulkner novel and a Cormac McCarthy novel.  Not only has the language changed over the past century, but the punctuation and length of sentence as well.  (Unfortunately, this linked post has an expletive in the middle, which definitely does not aid the reader in understanding.)

Also, in preparation for our CM Book Study I read sections from Charlotte Mason's Vol. 4, Ourselves this week.  Last night, we specifically discussed a quote from pages 10-11, in Book II, which states....
We are safest with those which have lived long enough to become classics; and this, for two reasons. The fact that they have not been allowed to die proves in itself that the authors have that to say, and a way of saying it, which the world cannot do without.  In the next place, the older novels and plays deal with conduct, and conduct is our chief concern in life.  Modern works of the kind deal largely with emotions, a less wholesome subject of contemplation. 
I found it interesting that Charlotte likened older novels to conduct and modern novels to emotion.  Ironically, Charlotte Mason lived from 1842-1923 so much of what she considered modern is now classic to modern society.

Lastly this morning, I read The 6 Risks of Reading Older Books.  Betsy's post and reasoning made me sad.  I was disappointed that she appeared to mock books like The Secret Garden, Understood Betsy, and Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm.  I wondered if she's actually ever read those books. And, I couldn't disagree more with her "Risk #6".   I believe our children will learn to be more discerning from a classic work that regards conduct than a modern work that plays on emotion.

As for me and my house, we will continue to read a variety of books with emphasis on classic literature.  I believe many of those classic titles foster truth, beauty and goodness.  How about you?  I'd love to hear your thoughts.  Do you prefer modern or classic lit?  Feel free to comment below...

Friday, March 4, 2016

Friday Findings: Plutarch's Lives, Dyslexia, Nature Study, and More...

Oh, it's Friday again!  The weeks seem to be flying by.  Tonight is our CM Book Study.  We're studying Principle 19 and I look forward to gathering.  I don't quite have the reading done, so I will be working through it today.  We are reading excerpts from Ourselves, which will be a change of pace from A Philosophy of Education since Charlotte wrote each of these books for entirely different purposes.

The kids have been plugging away with their studies.  We finished Trial and Triumph by Richard Hannula this week.  We also finished reading Aemilus Paulus last week, our second Plutarch's Lives. As previously mentioned, we used Anne White's AO study guide.

Speaking of Anne White and Plutarch, I highly recommend listening to Pam Barnhill's podcast, A Conversation with Anne White.  Anne gives a 101 on how to implement the study of Plutarch's Lives into your homeschool regimen.

Regarding dyslexia, How widespread is dyslexia? gives a great visual of this learning difference.

Brandy wrote a fabulous post this week titled, Are Narration and Discussion Interchangeable?  It's something I've thought about in the past.  I highly recommend reading the comments section after the post.  There is a lot of meat there.

With spring just around the corner, posts of nature study are in the air.  This week, Celeste at Joyous Lessons wrote Nature Study Outing: First Wildflowers and Early-Leafers and Cindy West at Our Westward Journey wrote Nature Study IS Science.  Both posts bring something different to the table.  I find Celeste's organic approach refreshing.  However, if you're new to nature study or just can't seem to get started, Cindy offers a guide to get you out the door.

Lastly, I really appreciated Mystie Winckler's Hits & Misses in Our Homeschool This Year post.  I love it when bloggers do follow-up posts to let us know how it's going or how it went.  I especially liked Mystie's post because it referenced resources and ideas I've been pondering for fall.  It gave me more food for thought.

Even though it's been a bit cooler this week, the snow continues to melt.  We are looking forward to unseasonably warm temps in the 50's again this weekend...which means more clothes on the line :)





Wednesday, March 2, 2016

Miracles on Maple Hill....


We read Miracles on Maple Hill by Virginia Sorensen for the February 5th/6th Grade Socractic Book Club discussion.  It was a much easier read than some of our other choices, but a delightful story just the same.

When her father returns from the war, a POW suffering from what appears to be PTSD, Marly's family retreats to Maple Hill.  Her grandmother's old house in the country and her mother's childhood haven, look to be the perfect place for father's recovery.  Upon arrival, they are met by Mr. Chris, an old neighboring farmer who believes the first miracle of the year is sap rising and maple syrup making.  Over the course of the year as the seasons change, miracles do happen on Maple Hill.

This delightful coming of age story will warm your heart.  It's set in rural Pennsylvania, post WWII.  The flora and fauna of Maple Hill aid in father's recovery.  Miracles on Maple Hill is a reminder of hope and the importance of family and friends in times of adversity.  The making of maple syrup is also a perfect fit for a great spring read!